My theory: Nate Silver is paying those Politico guys to say these silly things

by Andrew Gelman on June 24, 2013 · 4 comments

in Media

The question is, how could these guys at Politico say such foolish things (see John’s discussion here of some examples)? The usual explanation for smart people acting stupid is love, religion, or political ideology. But in this case I don’t see John Harris and Jim VandeHei being motivated by love or religion, and it seems to be part of their shtick that they don’t have much of an ideology.

So here’s my theory. Nate Silver is immensely successful. Nate Silver is a god. But overexposure goeth before destruction, and an haughty spirit before a fall. That is: to stay on top, Nate needs to be continually contrasted with easy-to-hate enemies. But this isn’t so easy. There are no more polls to unskew, and at this point even the fools know to be careful not to tangle with Nate.

So what does Nate do? He has to create some enemies. He’s floating high, so the enemies can’t be any bottom-feeding bloggers. The solution is brilliant. He pays off the staff at Politico to pick a fight with him. And this reminds us of what we all love about 538. Nate cares about the truth, not about sound bites. Nate’s secure in the knowledge that his site gets the hits. So he can just sit there smiling while the Politico guys take swings at him. It’s brilliant, really.

And what do the dudes at Politico get out of this? Beyond whatever Nate is paying them under the table, they get some short-term attention (as in this blog post!), also maybe they get on the short list for being hired by whatever new venture Tucker Carlson might be planning. Win-win-win.

{ 4 comments }

Chris Mealy June 24, 2013 at 10:38 pm

You’ve read Politico, right? You lost me at the “smart people” in “smart people acting stupid.”

eric June 24, 2013 at 11:04 pm

A great setup for a Tucker Carlson joke. I love it.

JG June 25, 2013 at 8:31 am

Harris and VandeHei are not dudes.

As a dude I find it offensive to have those two individuals lumped into my social identity group.

Ken Houghton June 25, 2013 at 11:02 am

“He’s floating high, so the enemies can’t be any bottom-feeding bloggers. The solution is brilliant. He pays off the staff at Politico…”

I see you’ve refuted your own argument within 1.5 sentences.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: